Failure Analysis Case History No. 006

Industry: Chemical Process
Specimen Description: Pressure Relief Valve
Material: Carbon steel
Environment: High pressure ethane/propane with CO, CO2, O2 and H20
A high-pressure relief valve (400 psig) failed at a weld while in service, resulting in a flammable gas leak and autorefrigeration of the valve. The leak caused a plant shutdown.
Time in Service: 3 years
Laboratory testing showed that the fracture surface of the failed weld was typical of cleavage. Hydrogem embrittlement was considered; however, the softness of the weld, appeared to preclude that failure mechanism. It was believed that the most logical explanation for the PSV valve failure was CO, CO2, H20 stress corrosion cracking. This little recognized cracking mechanism occurs in a high pressure CO, CO2, H20 environments. PPM levels of oxygen act as a cracking accelerator. Critical levels of CO are neccesary for cracking to occur. Stress relieving will slow cracking but will not eliminate it. Cracks can also occur in stress relieved base metal, depending on pressure stresses.


Contact Us

If you have questions or need our depth of experience to help with your issues...

Call us: 281-556-8774

Email us:


The safe operation of oil refineries in the United States is under constant more
When: January 30, 2017 - February 2, 2017 Where: Galveston Island more

View all articles

Stay Current

Sign up for our quarterly newsletter

covering updates on corrosion